Skip to main content

Newsweek's Tomasky Misses the Obvious

Ken Shepherd's picture

It's actually kind of funny to watch a liberal journalist, hit in the face with all the relevent data,  drawing anything but the painfully obvious conclusion.

Take Michael Tomasky of Newsweek/The Daily Beast, who chalks up President Obama's trouble in recent opinion polls to his spin doctor team in the White House (emphasis mine):


 

We were told, as I recall, that Barack Obama had to seek a debt deal with the Republicans to please independent voters. Well, the independent voters are speaking, and they don’t appear to be especially appeased. There’s a new Gallup poll just out showing that independent voters hate the deal. Their views on it are far more similar to the GOP’s than to the Democratic Party’s. Combine these data with the president’s approval numbers, which are swiftly heading south, and we have little choice but to conclude that this brilliant stratagem backfired. Isn’t it time for someone to say: this new White House political team is worse than the previous one?

First let me run you through the numbers. Americans disapprove of the deal by 46 to 39 percent. Democrats support it 58-28. Republicans oppose it 26-64. Independents oppose it 33-50. A second question asked of respondents: Was the deal a step forward or backward or neither with respect to “addressing the federal debt situation?” Democrats lined up 30-14-50. Republicans, 15-28-52. Independents, 16-25-50. Finally, independents also align more closely with Republicans on the question of whether the deal will have a good or bad effect on the economy. Whereas 29 percent of Democrats think the effect will be good, just 12 percent of independents and 8 percent of Republicans believe that.

Independents tend to agree with Republicans and Tea Partiers on the substance of the primary issue in the coming presidential year. But for Tomasky, that is a failure of Obama's political packaging, not his policy per se:

The fundamental problem appears to be the excessive fixation on Obama’s (forgive me for even using this word) “brand”—this “adult in the room” nonsense. Whenever I see those words in print anymore, usually in a background quote from a White House aide or a Democratic source trying gamely to be on-message, I hear strong and unsettling echoes of the 2008-vintage messianism. Does anyone buy this anymore, outside of what appears to be an increasingly bubble-ized White House? Those beloved independents certainly aren’t thinking of the president that way these days, and one doubts that even most of his supporters are.

Obama’s brand is and has by now long been determined by events and facts, not by White House spin and set pieces, or by vestigial remnants of the Days of Hope. Those events and facts are almost uniformly grim (except Libya, whose political gains will be fleeting or perhaps nonexistent). Adults get credit when the household is running smoothly and the kids are well behaved and pulling good grades. With none of those things happening, the adult in the room is precisely the last thing to want to be. But they refuse to change gears.

Watching this White House over these last several weeks has been like watching a time-lapse video of an apple rotting. We’re supposed to believe now that the jobs plan to be announced next month will change everything. Maybe. But what needs to change is the way the White House approaches politics. To what? To a simple, blunt, and deeply real-world truth: He’s not nearly as bad as the other guys, who are crazy. That’s all he’s got. That’s his “brand” now. If his people keep insisting on trying to package him the way they did three years ago, he won’t have even that.

Comments

#1 Ken

You might be able to better emphasize your point to Tomasky were your messaging better.

#2 The Most Interesting Part of This Story

Is that Newsweek still exists. That's pretty remarkable.

I haven't foggiest idea who Tamasky is. But if you say he exists, OK let it be so!

#3 Tamasky

Was the US political Editor for the Guardian, a British paper that is so far left it makes the old Newsweek look like the Wall Street Journal.

#4 I Have Read the Guardian

Reading the Guardian was very much like reading Mien Kampf. Why would anyone hire someone from that wing of the loony left? Those people aren’t holding on to reality by their fingernails because they lost all grip decades ago.

#5 Too little too late.

I wonder how many else in the media who gave free advertising space and used their bully pulpit to swindle the American electorate into buying Ear Leader as the great hope of modern civilization will start to cover their butts with such idiotic rhetoric. He is setting up Newsweak and every other media outlet who participated in that conspiracy to claim victim status. Tomasky is using the old chestnut of the thug who murders his parents and asks for clemency because he is an orphan.

#6 It's actually kind of funny

It's actually kind of funny to watch a liberal journalist, hit in the face...

Now that would be funnier still.

And we know the drill by now, Tomasky.

Obama's poor poll numbers are everyone else's fault except Obama's.

-And if you ask me, they are still way too high.

-Dave

Vote for the American in November

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.